Squarespace vs a custom website which is right for a small business?
Squarespace is known for polished templates you set up yourself. A custom website is designed and coded for you from scratch. Most small businesses don’t need the most expensive option — they need a site that looks professional, loads fast and turns visitors into calls. Here’s how the options compare, including a third path: a managed website plan.
Side by side
| Feature | Squarespace | Custom website | Managed plan (Aethely) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who builds it | You, from a template | A designer or developer | We do |
| Up-front cost | Low | Highest | None |
| Ongoing cost | Monthly subscription | Hosting plus paid updates | From $19/mo, edits included on Growth/Pro |
| Design | Polished templates | Anything you can pay for | Templates tailored to your business |
| Time from you | High | Medium (briefs and reviews) | Low |
| Updates | You make them | Billed per change | Included on Growth and Pro |
| Calls and leads | Contact forms | Whatever you build | AI receptionist and chatbot included |
Based on publicly available information as of October 2026. Other products change their plans; check their websites for current details.
When Squarespace or custom is the better choice
- Squarespace: you like design tools and have time to manage the site
- Custom: you need complex features, integrations or a unique brand experience
- Custom: you have the budget for both the build and ongoing developer time
When a managed plan is the better choice
- You want a professional site without doing it yourself
- You don’t want a large up-front bill
- You want the website to bring in calls, not just look nice
The short answer
Squarespace suits hands-on owners with time to spare; custom suits businesses with complex needs and a matching budget. For most local service businesses, a managed plan gives a professional result with the least effort and no big up-front cost.
Questions, answered.
Is Squarespace good for SEO?
It covers the basics well. Local rankings depend more on your Google Business Profile, reviews and local content than on which builder you use.
How much does a custom website cost?
It varies widely with scope — from a few thousand dollars to much more for complex sites. Get two or three quotes for the same brief to compare fairly.
Can I switch later?
Yes. Your content can move between platforms, though designs usually need rebuilding. Keep your domain in your own name so you can always move.
Want to see what Aethely would do for you?
Tell us a little about your business. A real person in Edmonton will get back to you within one business day.
Or call (780) 993-635214 days free · No contracts · No setup fee